Saturday, December 13, 2008
To bail or not to bail: the parallel between Detroit’s auto makers and Zamtel.
For years Detroit’s auto industry has provided the back born of the US manufacturing industry. The industry has given the middle class more than 13 million direct and indirect jobs.
And for more than 30 years, Detroit auto makers have successfully lobbied government to protect their market share against foreign car makers and tougher fuel efficiency standards.
However, as fuel prices spiraled ever upwards US consumers began to prefer foreigner cars especially Japanese cars with higher mileage.
Detroit therefore, began losing its market share and some southern states begun hosting Japanese car makers to meet the growing demand for foreign cars.
Last year, the feds finally increased the fuel efficiency standards after thirty years. The timing could not have been worse as the US economy had entered a recession leading up the crescendo of the current credit crunch that has brought Detroit, to the brink of bankruptcy.
Zambia Telecommunications Company (Zamtel) has also enjoyed government protection from foreign telecom operators for years. It has successfully lobbied the Zambian government to maintain exclusive control of the international gateway, and the domestic fixed phone lines market.
Like Detroit auto makers, Zamtel has offered Zambian consumers poor phone usage with very low mileage against spiraling charges. Consequently, Zambian consumers have preferred the efficient services of foreign telecom operators and now Zamtel hangs on the brink of insolvency.
Unlike the debate in the US where the debate is whether the US government should bail in with public funds to save Detroit and millions of US jobs, the debate in Zambia is whether the Zambian government should bail out of Zamtel ownership.
There are passionate views in both debates, as the auto bail out bill fell in the US Senate, senators across party lines shared fears of the demise of Detroit.
“I believe we must work swiftly to allow the domestic automotive industry to gain access to emergency assistance…..the risk in doing nothing is too great,” Sen. George Voinovich (R-Ohio).
“There are national security implications here, these companies also make the axles used on our military vehicles…. we have already yielded electronics and textiles….do you want to outsource the manufacture of tanks.” Debbie Stabenow (D-Michigan).
Despite ideological differences there is growing consensus that despite, it’s past mistakes, Detroit can not be allowed to fail. The Whitehouse is now expected to use part of the initial financial system bail out money to save Detroit auto makers.
In the debate to save Zamtel, there are differing views; there are proponents of unbundling and privatization while others favor further government recapitalization with restructuring.
While Zamtel‘s troubles stem from government ownership and the associated inefficiencies of government ownership regaining it’s viability is not contingent on the loss of its’ exclusive control of the international gateway. International investors might find, acquiring Zamtel more lucrative if the company retains control of its domestic and international infrastructure.
Zambian consumers are also, more likely to derive more mileage for their money spent on phone usage and the Zambian government would have cheaper means of addressing national security concerns if the company is retained as a single private entity versus unbundling.
Sunday, November 9, 2008
The reign of the vulgar gives way to a wise gentleman.

This has in part been, the premise of neo-conservatism as adapted by Irving Kristol the godfather of neo-conservatism and father of Bill Kristol of the weekly Standard, that those who have gained through inherited wealth the most opportunity to education and financial success, have a higher right to rule and govern the affairs of the nation.
Much further neo-conservatism at its core demands a preservation of social and economic inequality through taxation and limited government expenditure on social programs. The outrage of conservatives like Bill Kristol and Sean Hannity, at the prospect of an Obama presidency is explicitly rooted in the fear perceived or real of the demise of this inequality.
While, I embrace some conservative values such as preserving personal freedoms especially with to respect to religion and family; I find reprehensible the conservative agenda to maintain extreme economic disparity through the use of tax policies and government budgets.
The unifying of all Americans was first credited to Republican President Abraham Lincoln; however it is the current Republican Party that uses its taxation policy to maintain economic and social disempowerment. It disproportionately impacts minorities, especially African Americans given their history.
The Republican Party has always formulated tax policies that favor the protection of wealth over the accumulation of wealth. While Republican tax policy has protected income from inherited wealth by enacting zero or minimal tax rates for estate, capital and dividends taxes they have subjected income from labor (i.e. income and personal) to higher taxes.
In the last two months I have volunteered my time and money to the Obama campaign, because I believe, the Obama Presidency is certain to turn part of the conservative paradigm on its head. First the belief that the privilege to rule is the preserve of the elite and second that the free market should disproportionately reward wealth more than work.
It is not that I want affirmative action or communism, but as President Elect Obama has articulated, pragmatism in the way government taxes and spends public money.
Republicans in the past have attempted to starve government, by cutting taxes and social programs, the beast (Govt.) they claimed was demanding more, more and swallowing every resource. This spanned well, when government did not have the burden of wars or infrastructure development, now the Iraq and Afghan wars plus the repair costs of crumbling infrastructure has outstripped government income. The Republicans would have the middle class bear the brunt of funding the federal budget and expand expenditure through war expenses while resisting increases on capital gains or estate taxes.
The two bizarre celebrities that emerged from the Presidential race, Sarah Palin and Joe the plumber exposed the underlining hypocrisy of this conservative agenda.
Sarah Palin it turned out was an example of past and future results of children left behind / home schooling policy that fails to fill the enormous knowledge and funding gaps because Republicans have withheld federal funds to provide schools and parents more resources.
Joe the plumber is neither the entrepreneur nor the limited government proponent they made him out to be: in fact he is not even licensed to work as plumber and has been a recipient of government social program benefits.
So what will the reign of the forty-fourth President look like?
President Elect Obama has broad, almost unprecedented support; he embodies the diversity of America and the world both figuratively and literally perhaps this why most people feel a personal connection. He has offered to put government on the side of working people, to give the middle class a tax relief and expand opportunity for social and economic empowerment to all.
His outlook and governing philosophy lends confidence to social and economic policies that will bring into the mainstream, those Americans that have existed on fringes of America's social progression over the last hundred years.
“Let us remember that it was a man from this state who first carried the banner of the Republican Party to the White House--a party founded on the values of self-reliance, individual liberty, and national unity.
Those are values we all share, and while the Democratic Party has won a great victory tonight, we do so with a measure of humility and determination to heal the divides that have held back our progress. As Lincoln said to a nation far more divided than ours, "We are not enemies, but friends ... though passion may have strained it must not break our bonds of affection." And to those Americans whose support I have yet to earn--I may not have won your vote, but I hear your voices, I need your help, and I will be your president too.” President Elect Barack Obama.
Monday, September 1, 2008
Zambia's future:Old dog new tricks vs old tricks young dog?

Provincial executive committees in Luapula, Northern, North Western and Copperbelt have unanymously endorsed the candidature of Banda in the November polls, he said." (Xinhua)
If Rupiah Banda is the old dog, in this battle for succession, figutively speaking, he has certainly learnt a few new tricks otherwise how did he win the party people and keep the master's confidence at the same time?
While Mrs. Mwanawasa may not have taken to Rupiah Banda as a potential successor, a significant number of party powers seem to have fallen for the old dog charm, unbridled generosity. While Magande is urging financial discipline, Banda like grandpa is offering higher wages and increasing allowances for political leaders across the board.
"The MMD in Lusaka has endorsed the candidature of Vice President Rupiah Banda as the presidential candidate in the forthcoming presidential by-election with more joining in the calls.
MMD Lusaka Province secretary, Cleophas Chimembe said in a letter to the party’s national secretary Katele Kalumba that the provincial executive committee supported the application of Mr Banda as the most preferred candidate."
“We further state with conviction that Mr Banda is the right candidate for the job and we acknowledge the respect and confidence the late beloved President Mwanawasa had in him by appointing him to the office of vice president,” he said. (Times)
Magande is a relatively new political player and may have kept his master's voice and promise to fight corruption and waste but a party structure and public that are eager to satisfy immediate needs may not be attuned or pay attention to such noble yet causes that take a long time to bear benefits for all.
Magande, graduated from UNZA in 1970 with a degree in economics and mathematics, then added a masters in Agricultural economics from Makelele university. He has tremendous international experience, working for the World bank, ADB and ACP-EU. He has clearly used his immense economic and international experience to assuage Zambia's economic troubles, so why does he seem to be losing the battle even with the explicit support of Mwanawasa's widow?
Is old age and experience a greater charm than relative youth, excellent academic and professional credentials?
As in the US Presidential race, where Barack Obama faces a similar challenge from an old and experienced Mc Cain, old politicians apparently are more adept than old dogs in learning quickly and employing new tricks. They have both created just a little excitement amongst their political base to detract from the real issues of the campaign. While Rupiah Banda used money and more money to induce support, Mc Cain enlisted a beautiful woman as a running mate.
It has been said politics is a game of dirty tricks, new and old, I wait to see how this battle rolls out.
Friday, August 1, 2008
Rupiah Banda:unsavory consequence of Machiavellian Politics?
Machiavelli also notes that it is wise for a prince not to ally with a stronger force unless compelled to do so.
This kind of political strategy has increasingly gained prominence in modern day politics. In Zambia's recent political history, former Presidents have sought to carefully manage and retain institutions in a form that furthers rather than challenge their power. There has been untoward resistance to the reform of the institutions of government like parliament, electoral council and the judiciary.
Despite several constitutional reviews including the on-going NCC, there is still opposition to the reduction of executive authority, specifically, attempts to mitigate the power to appoint key members of the judiciary, the electoral council, government boards even government owned companies.
Perhaps more Machiavellian has been nature of appointments to the office of Vice President, in the recent past, we have had Nevers Mumba (2003/4), Lupando Mwape(2004/6) and present Rupiah Banda. All of whom had to be nominated to parliament and held no viable party position in the MMD. Essentially, they are outsiders brought in so close, to the principal power- the President, so that he has always remained more powerful, more appealing, less transient. In making such appointments, he may have employed the more important virtue of Machiavelli - having the wisdom to discern what ventures will come with the most reward and then pursuing it courageously.
In the US presidential race John McCain was asked what he thought the most important job of the Vice President is - " it is to inquire daily on the President's health" he said and " In my case , this is going to be very important". McCain is expected to appoint a more able running mate.
Sadly, it is the cruel hand of ill health that has brought Zambia, to the current political and constitutional limbo. In our case, Ruphiah Banda is hardly prepared nor appropriately positioned within the MMD, to continue the transcendent role of governing and managing the state.
Saturday, July 5, 2008
Mwanawasa 'is not dead'
Information Minister Mike Mulongoti said the reports had caused "panic and damage" for Zambians.
President Levy Mwanawasa, 59, is in intensive care at a hospital in Paris after suffering a stroke at an African Union summit in Egypt last weekend.
Vice-President Rupiah Banda said Mr Mwanawasa's condition was stable.......
South Africa's leader has retracted comments in which he said that Zambian President Levy Mwanawasa, 59, had died.
President Thabo Mbeki asked for a minute's silence on Thursday but his office later said reports of Mr Mwanawasa's death were "not true".
Zambia's Vice-President Rupiah Banda said Mr Mwanawasa had had a "satisfactory night" in Paris.
He was flown there from Egypt, where he had suffered a stroke on Sunday ahead of an African Union summit.
South African radio earlier quoted a spokesman who said he was from Zambia's High Commission as saying Mr Mwanawasa had died. ( BBC)
Thursday, July 3, 2008
Alas Mwanawasa is gone.....

Thu 3 Jul 2008, 8:12 GM
JOHANNESBURG, July 3 (Reuters) - Zambian President Levy Mwanawasa died in a Paris hospital on Thursday after suffering a stroke earlier this week, South Africa's Talk Radio 702 reported.
The radio quoted a Zambian High Commission spokesman as saying that Mwanawasa died earlier on Thursday morning. Mwanawasa was taken to hospital in Egypt just before an African Union summit on Monday and Tuesday and then transferred to Paris...
Wednesday, July 2, 2008
Political posturing: The dynamics of post Mwanawasa politics.
Bloomberg has this....
"July 2 (Bloomberg) -- Zambian President Levy Mwanawasa was flown to France last night for specialist treatment after suffering a mild stroke in Egypt on June 29, Vice-President Rupiah Banda said.
Mwanawasa was moved to a Paris hospital where he will undergo ``further medical treatment,'' Banda said in a statement in the Zambian capital, Lusaka, late yesterday."
My prayers are for our beloved Mwanawasa to recover, as grim as the prognosis of suffering two strokes, any other outcome is hard to come to grips with and indeed casts doubt on the future of our nation and the constitutional, political, economic and structural progression Zambia has made under Mwanawasa.
Vice President Rupiah Banda hardly strikes me as a reformer, he has certainly had his time from the UNIP era to a period of retirement. He lacks the necessary grip on contemporary and future challenges Zambia faces, in the wake of recent government and economic restructuring.
Would he provide the leadership Zambia needs to rein in the mines in order to bring Zambians benefits through taxation and fair employment opportunities?
Would he follow through with government restucturing, to make service delivery to average Zambians more responsive and effective?
Would he deliver the constitution, we have being crying out for?
On the opposition side, Michael Sata is equally ill equiped for our time in both health and idealogy.
UPND's Hakainde Hichilema may have youth and progressive ideas but his party lacks the grassroot framework and support to deliver him the presidency.
It maybe to the outcome of the battle between the old and the young Turks in the MMD to carry the mantle.
As Cho the Zambian economist/seer has outlined here the levers of our current constitution are clear.
Within MMD, Prof Clive Chirwa and Dr. Nevers Mumba may have to prove between them who has the grip and proximity to the MMD party machinery.
For this moment however, my duty as every Zambian is to pray for our President Mwanawasa and our first lady Maureen and the family that is our beloved nation.